Training Attention
New brain-imaging techniques could teach people to strengthen the parts of the brain that control attention.
By Emily Singer

How do surgeons focus intently on their patients for hours on end? Why do other people have difficulty finishing a book or listening to a lecture? Can they train themselves to improve, as they might train to run a marathon or play the violin?

Scientists hope to find answers to these questions by using a new variation on brain imaging that lets people watch detailed movies of their brains in action. If this new technology can indeed strengthen the brain areas that mediate attention, people with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) might have a drug-free way to improve their symptoms.

Functional magnetic resonance imagining (fMRI) measures blood flow in precise areas of the brain, giving scientists an indirect measure of the brain's activity patterns. While data collected from fMRI has traditionally taken days or weeks to analyze, newer algorithms and greater computing power have collapsed that time down to milliseconds. That means scientists -- and subjects -- can watch the brain in action.

Known as real-time fMRI, the technique has been used mostly as a scientific tool. But scientists are beginning to use real-time fMRI as a form of neural feedback to teach people to consciously control their brain activity. Preliminary studies by Stanford neuroscientist Sean Mackey and colleagues have shown that the technology can help people control chronic pain (see "Seeing Your Pain," July/August.) Now scientists are setting their sights on attention disorders such as ADHD.

When you're having a conversation with a friend in the middle of a cocktail party, your brain is assaulted with huge volumes of sensory information -- the clink of martini glasses, the nasal whine of a nearby conversation. Ideally, mechanisms in the brain filter out this extraneous information, allowing you to focus attention on your companion's voice. "We know the brain can home in on visual or auditory information," says Seung-Schik Yoo, a neuroscientist at Harvard Medical School in Boston. "But for some people, it's not that easy to do."

People with ADHD may have difficulty filtering out extraneous sounds, or may find it hard to focus on complex directions or a lengthy speech. Yoo and others want to see if fMRI feedback can help strengthen the attentional machinery in the brain.

"[Researchers] understand what parts of the brain are active when people are paying attention," says Peter Bandettini, director of the Functional MRI Core Facility at the National Institute of Mental Health in Bethesda, MD. "If you could focus on those areas, it's kind of like bootstrapping yourself to pay attention."

Yoo's experiments center on an area in the brain's temporal lobe that's involved in auditory attention. Subjects lie in an MRI scanner while listening for specific sounds. As they listen, they watch a monitor that displays the activity in this auditory brain area and try to consciously increase it. "We wanted to enhance the brain's ability to concentrate (or tune) to specific sounds in the middle of a noisy MRI scanner," says Yoo. "It's not easy. People have to watch a plot and listen to the sounds. All these things can be very distracting, but people eventually learn to control their thought processes."

Preliminary results show that subjects who recieved fMRI feedback were more likely to be able to increase brain activity in the target region than controls.

John Gabrieli, a neuroscientist at MIT, is planning similar tests, focusing on training the basal ganglia, a structure deep in the brain that's frequently abnormal in children with ADHD. This brain structure is involved in motor function and learning, and also the part of the brain where Ritalin, a common drug treatment for the disorder, binds most readily. "I think this will be one of the most striking applications [for real-time fMRI]," says Gabrieli.

Other scientists plan to use fMRI feedback to determine why some people have an exceptionally high capacity for attention. Rainer Goebel, a scientist at Maastricht University in the Netherlands, has used real-time fMRI to teach people to play the video game Pong entirely with their minds. He plans to use the technology to study people who seem to be able to put themselves into a hyper-focused state, such as race car drivers, as well as monks who consciously control their cognitive processes in a meditative state. (Preliminary evidence using traditional brain imaging has shown that experienced monks undergo unique changes in their brain activity during meditation, compared with novice meditators.) Goebel will determine how well these types of people perform during feedback training -- and try to discover what makes them different from most people.

The findings might shed light on how best to train attention and other aspects of cognitive processing. "Buddhist monks go sit on mountains for 30 years to find enlightenment in meditation. What if we can jump-start [the brain] without spending 30 years on a mountain?" asks Mackey. "That is still science fiction -- but it's an exciting thought."